The Short Take
CustomStickers.com vs PrintRunner is a battle between a sticker specialist and a broader commercial online printer.
PrintRunner has a respectable sticker and label catalog, including cut-to-size stickers, kiss-cut stickers, sticker sheets and rolls. It also offers materials like BOPP and vinyl, plus an online design tool. But CustomStickers.com is the better choice for most custom sticker buyers because it delivers stronger quality, far better value and a simpler sticker-first experience.
PrintRunner is flexible. CustomStickers.com is the better sticker buy.
The Scorecard
| Category | Winner | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Sticker Quality | CustomStickers.com | Better overall quality score and stronger specialist positioning |
| Price And Value | CustomStickers.com | PrintRunner performs poorly on value in our vinyl sticker benchmark |
| Formats | PrintRunner | Strong range of singles, kiss-cut, sheets and rolls |
| Proofing And Support | CustomStickers.com | Better sticker-specific support and proofing value |
| Turnaround | Close | PrintRunner is fast, but CustomStickers.com has the better total package |
| Best Overall | CustomStickers.com | Better for most custom sticker orders |
PrintRunner has tools. CustomStickers.com has the stronger sticker outcome.
Where PrintRunner Looks Good
PrintRunner is not a weak competitor. It offers several useful sticker formats, including cut-to-size singles, kiss-cut stickers, sticker sheets and roll stickers. It also supports custom shapes, custom sizes and materials for different needs.
For waterproof uses, PrintRunner points customers toward BOPP. Its vinyl sticker page also describes vinyl stickers as waterproof, UV-resistant, fade-resistant and durable enough for outdoor gear, car bumpers, laptops and reusable tumblers.
PrintRunner also has an online design tool, which is helpful if you do not already have artwork prepared. It accepts a wide range of file formats and offers free shipping on qualified orders.
So yes, PrintRunner is a real online printer with real sticker options.
The problem is value.
Where CustomStickers.com Pulls Ahead
CustomStickers.com is more focused, and that focus pays off.
It offers thick vinyl stickers with waterproof, tear proof and sun proof durability. It includes free online proofs, free shipping in the U.S. and the ability to approve or request proof revisions before printing.
In our sticker matrix, CustomStickers.com is the top overall performer. It scores especially well on quality, price, customer service and overall average. PrintRunner scores much lower overall, with price being the biggest issue in the benchmark.
That gives the comparison a very clear shape: PrintRunner has formats and flexibility, but CustomStickers.com is the better buy for most people.
Quality: Good Enough Versus Great
PrintRunner’s quality is not the issue in the same way it is with some weaker multiproduct printers. PrintRunner offers waterproof materials, vinyl options and a fairly broad sticker catalog. Its sticker products can work well for business use, events and labels.
But CustomStickers.com still has the stronger quality profile in our scoring. It is a sticker specialist, not a general online printer with a sticker section. That distinction matters when you care about cutlines, laminate, color, durability and repeat consistency.
PrintRunner is good enough for many sticker and label jobs.
CustomStickers.com is better when the sticker is important.
That might sound dramatic, but it is practical. If the sticker is going on a customer package, a laptop, a water bottle, a merch table or a product insert, you want the cleaner result.
Price And Value: The Deciding Round
This is where CustomStickers.com wins hard.
Our internal notes flag PrintRunner’s vinyl sticker pricing as extremely poor value for the benchmark order. That does not mean every PrintRunner sticker order will be overpriced, but it does mean buyers should pay close attention before assuming PrintRunner is the better deal.
CustomStickers.com has the opposite value story. It combines high-quality vinyl stickers, aggressive pricing, free online proofs and free shipping. That makes the final offer easier to recommend.
PrintRunner may be useful if you are already ordering other print products and want stickers added to the same vendor flow. But for custom stickers alone, CustomStickers.com gives you a cleaner value proposition.
No one wants to overpay for stickers and then pretend it was a strategic brand investment. Sometimes it was just an expensive sticker.
Design And Ordering Tools
PrintRunner has a stronger built-in design tool story. If you do not have a finished design, you can use its online design tool to add text, shapes, colors and uploaded images. It also accepts many file formats, which is helpful for businesses working with different design assets.
CustomStickers.com is more proof-focused. The flow is simple: upload artwork, get a proof, approve it or request revisions. That is better for buyers who already have artwork and want the sticker produced correctly.
So PrintRunner wins if you need to design from scratch inside the ordering system. CustomStickers.com wins if you care more about the production result.
For most businesses and creators, artwork usually already exists. They have a logo, a mascot, a product label, a QR code or an illustration. In that situation, a clean proofing workflow matters more than a built-in design playground.
Customer Service And Proofing
PrintRunner has a decent service reputation in the notes, especially when fixing problems. Its official sticker pages also mention assistance from sticker experts for material questions and custom needs.
CustomStickers.com still gets the nod because its service model is more sticker-specific and proof-oriented. Free online proofs and revision options are built into the value proposition. That matters for custom shapes, small text, QR codes and designs with detailed edges.
The best customer service in sticker printing happens before something is printed. Once 500 incorrect stickers arrive, everyone is just managing disappointment in a box.
CustomStickers.com gives buyers a stronger checkpoint before that happens.
Turnaround And Shipping
PrintRunner can be fast. Its sticker pages promote fast turnaround, and its vinyl page lists production times for cut-to-size vinyl and roll stickers. It also offers free shipping on qualified orders.
CustomStickers.com also offers fast production and free shipping in the U.S. In our scoring, CustomStickers.com remains the stronger total choice because its turnaround is paired with better quality, price and support.
If speed is your only concern, PrintRunner deserves consideration. If speed, quality and price all matter together, CustomStickers.com wins.
Best Use Cases
Choose CustomStickers.com for:
- Custom vinyl stickers
- Die-cut logo stickers
- Waterproof stickers
- Product packaging stickers
- Laptop and water bottle stickers
- Artist merch
- Event stickers
- Repeat business orders
Choose PrintRunner for:
- Sticker orders bundled with other commercial print products
- Roll stickers and label-style jobs
- Buyers who want an online design tool
- Businesses already using PrintRunner
- Projects where format flexibility matters more than sticker value
Pros And Cons
CustomStickers.com Pros
- Better overall score in our sticker matrix
- Stronger sticker quality
- Much better value
- Free online proofs
- Free U.S. shipping
- Better for durable custom vinyl stickers
- Better for businesses, artists and repeat orders
CustomStickers.com Cons
- Not as broad as a general commercial printer
- Less built-in design-tool depth than PrintRunner
- Best for customers with artwork ready
PrintRunner Pros
- Wide range of sticker formats
- Cut-to-size, kiss-cut, sheets and rolls
- BOPP and vinyl options
- Online design tool
- Custom sizes and shapes
- Useful for broader commercial print orders
PrintRunner Cons
- Poor value in our vinyl sticker benchmark
- Lower overall sticker score
- More general printer than sticker specialist
- Not the best choice for premium custom sticker value
Final Verdict
PrintRunner is a capable online printer. It has useful sticker formats, material options, custom sizing and design tools. If you already use PrintRunner for other print products, it may be convenient.
But CustomStickers.com is the better choice for custom stickers.
In this CustomStickers.com vs PrintRunner comparison, CustomStickers.com wins on quality, value and overall confidence. PrintRunner has flexibility. CustomStickers.com has the better sticker-first offer.